Better to Memorialize Victims of Capitalism, Not Communism

[Oscar]

We would do better to memorialize the victims of capitalism, not communism

[ http://rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/gerry-c ... ot-communi ]

By Gerry Caplan | April 8, 2015

EXCERPT:

Communism collapsed of its own failings in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe a quarter of a century ago. Some Canadians who once had the misfortune to live under communism in Eastern Europe, and some of their descendants, now want to erect a monument in Ottawa to memorialize the victims of communism. The Harper government agrees; there are votes to be had here. But there are also issues.

This memorial has little to do with Canada beyond these voters. As squalid as the record of communism has been, Canadians have fled all kinds of ugly regimes over the decades. Do we memorialize every one of them? And do Canadians with no links whatever to Eastern Europe even care about an increasingly distant past? After all, 1.2 million of us contentedly holidayed in Cuba last year. For most Canadians, communism is history, not a living issue.

There's a second issue that has received much attention. The proposed memorial would be in the heart of downtown political Ottawa. Except for those who chose this site and the Harper government, just about everyone else believes it to be inappropriate. But it's axiomatic: whenever the vast majority of authoritative opinion challenges this government, the government wins.

I find myself torn. On the one hand, communism's calamitous record should not be forgotten. It teaches a crucial lesson: that true believers, those who believe any means however extreme justifies their end, are a danger to the world. On the other hand, there are far more pressing causes that deserve to be prominently memorialized by Canada.

My genocide scholar colleagues, for example, believe overwhelmingly that the treatment of Aboriginal peoples here (and the U.S.) constitutes genocide under the United Nations Convention on genocide. This is not just history. It roils Canada still. Yet there is no memorial to this shameful aspect of our own evolving story.

Nor must we ignore the appalling toll that capitalism has taken over the centuries, from the slave trade to war, colonialism, neo-colonialism, depressions, recessions, sweat shops, child labour, starvation wages, and so much more. Countless hundreds of millions of people have suffered from the exploitative dynamic of capitalism and continue to do so. This is not just history. Victims of the system, past and present, surely deserve to be remembered and memorialized. And in many ways, aboriginal peoples are victims not only of racism but of capitalist greed for their land.

The perfect place for such a memorial exists in Ottawa right now. The symbolism is made to order. It's right in the political heart of the city, kiddy corner to the Supreme Court. It's where the government seems determined to situate the memorial to the victims of communism. But it's far more appropriate for remembering the victims of capitalism, including Canada's First People. These injustices continue to this day.