A progression of tiny cuts make democracy a sham
http://www.thestar.com/opinion/article/654014
By James Travers National Affairs Columnist OTTAWA June 20, 2009
From acrylics to zippers, inventive Canadians are surprisingly good at giving the world new stuff it wants. Now this country is perfecting something no one needs. It's sham-ocracy, the illusion of government accountable to the people.
Even among mad scientists and crazy ideas, sham-ocracy is exceptional. It alone is designed not to function as advertised, to thwart its users. Gears don't mesh, levers disconnect and the whole is less than the sum of its parts.
Still, as a folly it's a magnificent piece of work. Its Gothic facades, theatrical forums and mahogany history are as fantastic as any theme park. It whirs and clanks, billows smoke and oozes importance. It's an icon and, all in all, a pretty good show.
No single person, political party or prime minister can hog the credit. Sham-ocracy is as much a group project as a shared burden. Begun in a 1980s Liberal effort to impose coherence and control on helter-skelter departments, agencies and spending, it's spreading like cholera in the time of Conservatives.
Slower than light or sound, its speed is still remarkable. On April 4 the Toronto Star published an essay, available at thestar.com/Travers, pulling apart the cracked and broken links in the chain binding Parliament, politicians and civil servants to citizens. Today the paper begins a close examination of the sorry state of federal governance. Between then and now, the pace of change has been startling, if sadly predictable.
Parliament lost more of its defining control over the public purse when the Prime Minister slipped $3 billion in public spending behind closed cabinet doors.
Oversight was blinkered again this week when the new federal budget office was denied the independence needed to probe and explain how Ottawa spends.
Voters' control over their elected representatives was again eroded when Liberals, like Conservatives, saved obedient incumbent MPs from the discipline and inconvenience of nomination contests.
Power is sliding farther away from the Commons and cabinet to concentrate in the Prime Minister's Office as a presidential-style spokesman increasingly becomes the administration's public voice.
Alone, none slices deep. As part of a progression they are killing democracy with cuts so small and sharp they are hardly noticed.
- - - -SNIP - - -
There are as many reasons for democracy becoming sham-ocracy as there are fixes. Over the coming weeks and months the Star will deconstruct them. But at the inquiry's epicentre is a singular concern. In perpetuating a fraud, politicians risk making Parliament another Eaton's, an institution more evocative of the past than relevant to the present or future.
James Travers' column appears Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday.
- - - -
TRAVERS: award-winning national columnist and former executive managing editor for the Toronto Star, died on Thursday March 3, 2011.
http://www.thestar.com/news/canada/columnists/
94626--travers-james
===========
The New Solitudes
http://www.walrusmagazine.com/articles/
2011.03-politics-the-new-solitudes/
Canada was once defined by the schism between English and French. Today, our divide is increasingly ideological. Can it be bridged?
By Erna Paris Illustration by Barry Blitt Politics From the March 2011 magazine
It was November 26, 2009, and I happened to be in Ottawa with a few hours to spare; so, on a citizen’s whim, I decided to drop in on Question Period in Canada’s House of Commons. I was a small girl the first time I sat in the historic visitors’ gallery that looms over the rows of members’ seats on both sides of the political divide. My father was determined that his children witness what he thought were essential places and events, and the House was high on his parental to-do list. I was properly impressed by the sight of grown-ups debating across the parliamentary aisle, waving sheaves of papers at one another and occasionally jabbing the air with their index fingers. I was too young to understand what they were talking about, but Dad’s lesson sank in, and I’ve been attending Question Period intermittently ever since.
In retrospect, I’m glad I visited the House that day, although I didn’t feel that way afterward. I thought I knew enough about our dysfunctional Parliament, but I wasn’t prepared for the dismay I felt as I watched Canada’s elected members challenge one another over one of the most critical issues to confront the country in a generation. The debate centred on the scandalous detainee transfer affair, which had once again exploded into public view. Richard Colvin, formerly a high-ranking diplomat in Afghanistan, had revealed that for seventeen months, starting in May 2006, he had informed his superiors in Ottawa that prisoners detained by the Canadian military, then transferred to Afghan security forces, were being tortured. His reports were consistently ignored, he charged. Worse still, he was ordered to stop putting his intelligence gathering into writing.
MORE:
http://www.walrusmagazine.com/articles/
2011.03-politics-the-new-solitudes/
= = = = = =
Fresh Issue for Spring Election: Democracy
http://murraydobbin.ca/2011/02/28/
fresh-issue-for-spring-election-democracy/
by Murray Dobbin Posted: 28 Feb 2011 11:36 AM PST
The odds now seem to favour a spring election, as Stephen Harper headed out across the country with his cabinet ministers to announce over $300 million in goodies. In anticipating yet another campaign, it is worth remembering that without the NDP, Canadian politics (outside Quebec) would look an awful lot like the U.S.: two political parties, economically and socially right-wing, both with a recent history of dismantling the activist state and gutting its revenue base through huge tax cuts. All the while pretending to compete for our hearts and minds.
To be sure, the Conservatives — who should rightfully be called the Republican Party — are by several degrees worse than the Liberal Party. Stephen Harper runs a ruthless autocracy with contempt for every aspect of democratic governance from watch dog organizations to parliamentary committees to access to information, and topped off with a relentless assault on the political culture through the defunding of civil society.
It now turns out that the Harper government may be much more corrupt than even the existing record shows. The Canadian Press did an FOI on the Integrity Commissioner’s office formerly headed up by the now discredited Christiane Ouimet. The documents revealed 42 of the 228 cases under scrutiny involved alleged misuse of taxpayer dollars, approximately 50 involved charges of “gross mismanagement” and an incredible 60 complaints involved contraventions of Acts of Parliament. Not a single complaint resulted in any action.
MORE:
http://murraydobbin.ca/2011/02/28/
fresh-issue-for-spring-election-democracy/
= = = =
Canada’s Deepening Democracy Crisis
http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php? ... &aid=19705
by Murray Dobbin Global Research, June 13, 2010
Murray Dobbin's Blog - 2010-05-03
http://murraydobbin.ca/
Canada is in the midst of a crisis in democracy unique in its history. There is simply no other historical example that one can compare it to. It is multi-faceted and it affects every aspect of our national politics and political discourse. It is inexorably eroding the political fabric of the country and therefore our viability as a democratic nation.
First, we have a government so contemptuous of democracy that it is utterly unapologetic in trying to impose on the country an agenda opposed by probably 75 per cent of the population — treating its minority status not as a mandate to work with other parties but as an irritating impediment to re-engineering the country along the lines defined by the U.S. Christian right.
MORE:
http://www.globalresearch.ca/index.php? ... &aid=19705